Ill., Wis. school districts OK to use church-run camp
Alliance Defending Freedom letter sets record straight
Monday, Mar 18, 2013
Attorney sound bites: Jeremy Tedesco | Rory Gray
EAST TROY, Wis. — Alliance Defending Freedom sent a letter to seven school districts in Illinois and Wisconsin Friday debunking legal claims and misinformation provided by an atheist group. The letter reassures the school districts that, contrary to the atheists’ claims, taking students on field trips to participate in non-religious educational programs at a church-run camp is constitutional.
“Public schools are tasked with providing foundational education, not engaging in unconstitutional discrimination,” said Senior Legal Counsel Jeremy Tedesco. “If the Freedom From Religion Foundation wants public schools to remain neutral toward religion, why is it asking them to discriminate against camps with successful non-religious programs just because Christians happen to run them? We hope that school districts will stand up to illegitimate demands made by atheist groups who distort the meaning of the First Amendment.”
Freedom From Religion Foundation sent letters to several public school districts after they conducted field trips to Timber-lee Christian Center this year. The group claims such field trips are unconstitutional since “public schools may not advance or promote religion.”
But the Alliance Defending Freedom letter explains that “the Timber-lee field trip program is neutral towards religion and constitutional under the First Amendment.” Therefore, the letter says, Timber-lee’s program must be judged by its educational merits, not the camp’s religious identity. For three decades, Timber-lee has offered “the best assortment of secular educational programs available to supplement the public school curriculum and help students learn the state standards it is designed to teach.”
The letter points out that Timber-lee does not require public school districts that use its facilities or participate in its programs to agree with its religious beliefs and that the courts have never universally banned public school districts “from using private facilities owned by a religious organization for any conceivable secular purpose.”
“Using the educational resources Timber-lee offers is in the academic interest of both schools and students,” said Litigation Counsel Rory Gray. “Good educational experiences should never be sacrificed simply because a select few misunderstand the First Amendment.”
“Public schools are tasked with providing foundational education, not engaging in unconstitutional discrimination,” said Senior Legal Counsel Jeremy Tedesco. “If the Freedom From Religion Foundation wants public schools to remain neutral toward religion, why is it asking them to discriminate against camps with successful non-religious programs just because Christians happen to run them? We hope that school districts will stand up to illegitimate demands made by atheist groups who distort the meaning of the First Amendment.”
Freedom From Religion Foundation sent letters to several public school districts after they conducted field trips to Timber-lee Christian Center this year. The group claims such field trips are unconstitutional since “public schools may not advance or promote religion.”
But the Alliance Defending Freedom letter explains that “the Timber-lee field trip program is neutral towards religion and constitutional under the First Amendment.” Therefore, the letter says, Timber-lee’s program must be judged by its educational merits, not the camp’s religious identity. For three decades, Timber-lee has offered “the best assortment of secular educational programs available to supplement the public school curriculum and help students learn the state standards it is designed to teach.”
The letter points out that Timber-lee does not require public school districts that use its facilities or participate in its programs to agree with its religious beliefs and that the courts have never universally banned public school districts “from using private facilities owned by a religious organization for any conceivable secular purpose.”
“Using the educational resources Timber-lee offers is in the academic interest of both schools and students,” said Litigation Counsel Rory Gray. “Good educational experiences should never be sacrificed simply because a select few misunderstand the First Amendment.”
- Pronunciation guide: Tedesco (Tuh-DESS’-ko)
Alliance Defending Freedom is an alliance-building, non-profit legal organization that advocates for the right of people to freely live out their faith.
# # # | Ref. 40409