Soule v. Connecticut Association of Schools
Description: Ever since the Connecticut Interscholastic Athletic Conference adopted a policy that allows males who identify as female to compete in girls’ athletic events, boys have consistently deprived Selina Soule, Alanna Smith, Chelsea Mitchell, and Ashley Nicoletti of honors and opportunities to compete at elite levels. CIAC’s policy is at odds with Title IX, a federal law designed to create equal opportunities for women in education and athletics.
Court to consider whether CT athletic association can abolish girls-only sports
Press call video (2021-02-26): Roger Brooks, Selina Soule, Alanna Smith, and Chelsea Mitchell
B-roll: Alanna Smith | Ashley Nicoletti | Alanna Smith and Ashley Nicoletti | Terry Miller wins race over Selina Soule (2020-02-01) | Terry Miller wins race over Alanna Smith (2019-04-20) | Terry Miller wins race over Alanna Smith and Chelsea Mitchell (2019-06-03) | Terry Miller wins race over Selina Soule and Alanna Smith (2019-06-03) | Terry Miller and Andraya Yearwood win race over Chelsea Mitchell (2018-06-04)
WHO: Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys
WHAT: Available for media interviews following hearing on motion to dismiss in Soule v. Connecticut Association of Schools
WHEN: Following hearing, which begins at 10 a.m. EST on Friday, Feb. 26
WHERE: Oral arguments can be viewed online; to schedule an interview, contact ADF Media Relations Specialist AnnMarie Pariseau at (480) 417-3975 or submit a request online
HARTFORD, Conn. – Alliance Defending Freedom Senior Counsel Roger Brooks and ADF Legal Counsel Christiana Holcomb will be available for media interviews Friday following a hearing in federal district court in which the Connecticut Interscholastic Athletic Conference is seeking to dismiss the lawsuit of several female athletes. The high school track competitors are challenging a policy that allows biological males who claim a female identity to compete in girls’ athletic events.
Ever since the CIAC adopted its policy, boys have consistently deprived Selina Soule, Alanna Smith, Chelsea Mitchell, and Ashley Nicoletti, of honors and opportunities to compete at elite levels. Mitchell, for example, would have won the 2019 state championship in the women’s 55-meter indoor track competition, but because two males took first and second place, she was denied the gold medal. Soule, Smith, and Nicoletti likewise have been denied medals and/or advancement opportunities.
“Female athletes deserve fair competition—an equal opportunity to compete, achieve, and win. But competition is no longer fair when males are allowed to compete in girls’ sports,” said Holcomb. “Males will always have inherent physical advantages over comparably talented and trained girls; that’s the reason we have girls’ sports in the first place. Our clients have already had the demoralizing experience of losing to male runners; this should not be allowed to continue. These committed female athletes—and young women across the country—deserve an opportunity that’s truly equal, without being sidelined by males dominating their sport.”
“I’ve spent my entire life training to be a champion in my sport,” Connecticut student Chelsea Mitchell, one of the athletes ADF represents, said. “But Connecticut has changed the rules and cheated me—and countless other female athletes—of the equality we deserve on the field. There are basic biological differences between boys and girls, and when we ignore this in sports, girls like me pay the price by missing out on medals and chances to compete. All girls deserve the opportunity to compete on a fair and level playing field, and no female athlete should have to experience what I have experienced. That’s why I’m fighting back.”
“Playing sports and training to be my best is a huge part of who I am,” added another of the athletes, Alanna Smith. “Many of my family members have been professional athletes, and I’m proud to have set my own records and achieved lots of my personal goals. But when I was a freshman, everything changed. When I realized I’d be competing against a biological male in the girls’ track meet—an athlete who had previously competed in the men’s division—I felt defeated before even stepping on to the track. Here in Connecticut, two biological boys have set 17 state meet records—times that female athletes like me have little hope of breaking. Girls shouldn’t be sidelined in their own sports, and that’s why I am standing up to restore fairness to my sport.”
ADF attorneys asked the U.S. Department of Education to investigate in June 2019 and filed the lawsuit Soule v. Connecticut Association of Schools in the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut the following February. Following its months-long investigation into the CIAC and Connecticut school districts, DOE issued a letter of impending enforcement action, finding that the athletic conference’s policy allowing males who identify as female to compete in girls’ athletic events disadvantages female athletes, denies them equal athletic opportunities, and violates federal law. On Tuesday, DOE reversed its position under the Biden administration and withdrew its letter.
Alliance Defending Freedom is an alliance-building, non-profit legal organization committed to protecting religious freedom, free speech, parental rights, and the sanctity of life.
# # # | Ref. 72000
Additional resources: Soule v. Connecticut Association of Schools
Scroll down to view additional resources pertaining to this case and its surrounding issue
Previous News Releases
- Alanna Smith’s Story (3:58): YouTube | Vimeo
- Selina Soule’s Story (3:15): YouTube | Vimeo
- Boys competing in girls’ sports? It’s time to stand for fair play (1:40): YouTube | Vimeo
- Restore fairness to women’s sports (media compilation video) (3:56)
- Should “transgender women” be allowed to compete in women’s sports? (4:14)
- Alanna Smith (b-roll) (8:35)
- Ashley Nicoletti (b-roll) (7:52)
- Alanna Smith and Ashley Nicoletti (b-roll) (1:06)
- Terry Miller wins race over Selina Soule (2020-02-01) (0:12)
- Terry Miller wins race over Alanna Smith (2019-04-20) (0:13)
- Terry Miller wins race over Alanna Smith and Chelsea Mitchell (2019-06-03) (0:29)
- Terry Miller wins race over Selina Soule and Alanna Smith (2019-06-03) (0:20)
- Terry Miller and Andraya Yearwood win race over Chelsea Mitchell (2018-06-04) (0:27)
Christiana Holcomb serves as legal counsel for Alliance Defending Freedom, where she is a key member of the Center for Christian Ministries. Since joining ADF in 2012, Holcomb has worked to protect the constitutionally protected freedom of churches, Christian schools, and Christian ministries to exercise their faith without government interference. She has also strongly advocated for the right of pastors and churches to be free from IRS censorship via the unconstitutional Johnson Amendment and has defended the bodily privacy rights of students. Holcomb earned her J.D. in 2010 from Oak Brook College of Law and Government Policy, where she graduated first in her class and served as a teaching assistant in criminal law. Also in 2010, Holcomb completed the ADF leadership development program to become a Blackstone Fellow. She is admitted to the state bar of California, the U.S. Supreme Court, and numerous federal district and appellate courts.
Roger G. Brooks serves as senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom, where he is a key member of the Center for Conscience Initiatives. Brooks focuses his efforts on protecting freedom of speech, free exercise of religion, student privacy, and parental rights. Prior to joining ADF in 2018, Brooks worked with the New York law firm of Cravath, Swaine & Moore for 25 years, 19 of those as a partner in the litigation department. Brooks received an A.B. from Princeton University, followed by a master’s degree in history and a Juris Doctor from the University of Virginia. After law school, Brooks clerked with the Hon. John D. Butzner, Jr., of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit. He received his Master of Divinity from Regent College Seminary in Vancouver, British Columbia. Brooks served on the board of ADF (2012-2014) and on the board of the Christian Legal Society (2002-2011). He is a member of the state bars of New York and North Carolina.